Key Findings
The AI model forecasts Q3 EPS of $1.45 versus Street consensus of $1.71, a 15% miss. However, Gemini raised its revenue estimate above consensus ($505M vs $500M) based on beauty channel strength.
Thesis
Gemini's bear case views Q3 as a 'clearing event where Helen of Troy prioritizes cash conversion over margin percentage.' The model points to Q2's $529M inventory pileup as evidence of a 'fundamental reset, not a blip.' The margin math is stark: inventory clearance discounts projected to compress margins by 350 basis points YoY, partially offset by beauty segment mix improvement (+120 bps).
What This Means
This is a classic inventory overhang story. Gemini's 85% confidence level suggests high conviction in the margin compression thesis. The Ulta Beauty read-through for the Dr. Dre brand provides external validation for the revenue resilience view, even as margins suffer. Investors should watch gross margin closely for signs of the clearing event.